Blasphemy Laws in Pakistan Penal Code.
Until 1980 the penal code enforced in Pakistan was in its original
form of 1860. It was the British government that established these
laws in the subcontinent being British colony. Penal Code section
295 provided punishment for those who destroyed, damaged or defiled
any place of worship or emblem of faith, with the intention to insult
the religion of any class of persons or the knowledge that any class
of persons is likely to consider such destruction as an insult.
Two years imprisoment was the maximum punishment for some one accused
of such an offence.
In 1927 amendments were made to this formulation and Section 295-
A was added. According to this, punishment could be doled out to
those who had the "deliberate and malicious intention of outraging"
the religious sentiments of any class of citizens, by words written
or spoken, or by visible signs. The importance of the requirement
that "deliberate and malicious intention" of the accused
must be proved was greatly emphasized upon, in order to avoid chilling
valuable speech. Since without such an intent requirement a simple
statement of any alternative religious belief could become punishable,
if it had the residual effect of "outraging" an overly
sensitive and too easily offended person.
These laws were designed to curb religious violence, as religious
and sectarian issues were commonly used at that time to manipulate
political gain. The main purpose of these laws was to protect the
religious feelings of all citizens with no preference given to any
religion sect or group and to develop understanding and harmony
among all citizens equally.
In the present situation it is most unfortunate that these laws
made to establish religious tolerance have been amened in ways which
seriously undermine that tolerance. Pakistani govenunents, in their
zeal to Islamize their laws, have turned a blind eye to the basic
reihts of their citizens. Their passion to Islamize the entire Pakistani
society has led to serious abuses against the Religious minorties.
Under the dictatorship of Mohammed Zia -Ul- Haq, amendments were
added to the Pakistan Penal Code. Section 298 -A was added in 1980.
On use of derogatort remarks, respect of holy personages. whoever
by words, either spoken or written or by visible representation,
or by any imputation,innuendo or insinuation, directly or indirectly.
defiles the sacred name of any wife or member of the family of prophet
Mohammad, subject to three years imprisonment.
In 1982, another amendment was made and section 295-B was added
in PPC, punishable with imprisonment of life.In 1986, section 295-C,
was added, the most serious, controversial and presently invoked
amendment was made, a capital punishment of death penalty.
In each of these amendments,298-A, 295-B and 295-C, the necessity
to establish the delibirate and malicious intention of the accused
is totally avoided. The measure of guilt depends entirely upon the
subjective perception and sentiment of the hearer. The untention
and knowledge of the accused is not taken into account easily allowing
for prosecution of imputation, innuendo,or insinuation, directly
or indirectly. The terms ' derogatory remarks ' or ' defile the
sacred name ' are very vogue and broad based. Blame can easily be
placed, and is used as rivalary and personel grudges against christians.
The accused is snared in the web of the Pakistani Islamic Judical
System. Its very interesting that prior to 1980 there were almost
no allegations of blasphemy.
There have been many arrest of christians under section 295-B
&C in pakistan. some have been brutally murderd in day light
from hands of redical muslims, some killed in jails and police lock
ups. Its fact that accused under blasphemy are not safe and cant
fairly in trials of courts.
|